Two prints, one shared muslin build
The Butterfly Bib and Mushroom Bib from Clementine Kids look like a simple print choice, but the supplied product records show a few practical differences that matter at mealtime. Both are double-layered absorbent muslin bibs measuring 8 inches wide by 9 inches tall, and both secure with 8-inch braided ties. That shared size and tie closure mean the decision comes down to design, reversibility, and care details rather than fit or absorbency.
What both bibs share
- Butterfly Bib: Double layered absorbant muslin, 8" wide, 9" tall, secure with 8" braided ties. These dimensions and the tie closure are the core fit and function details, and they match the Mushroom Bib exactly.

Butterfly Bib - Mushroom Bib: Measures 8 inches wide by 9 inches tall, ties securely with 8 inch braided strings, double layered absorbent muslin. Confirms the same size and muslin construction as the Butterfly Bib, so neither bib has a fit advantage on paper.

Mushroom Bib
Where the two bibs actually differ
- Design and reversibility: The Mushroom Bib is reversible, with a foraged mushroom print on one side and a solid rusty red on the other. The Butterfly Bib is described with an adorable butterfly design but no reversible feature is mentioned in the supplied record.
- Care instructions: The Mushroom Bib record states it is easy to clean in the washing machine. The Butterfly Bib record says it is adjustable and easy to clean, but does not specify machine washing.
- Price: The Butterfly Bib is listed at USD 6.60 (compared to a USD 10.00 comparison price), while the Mushroom Bib is USD 6.80 (also compared to USD 10.00). The difference is small.
Mushroom Bib details that affect daily use
- Mushroom Bib: Reversible mushroom and solid color design. A reversible bib gives you two looks in one, which can be handy if you want a solid option for outings or a print for home.
- Mushroom Bib: Easy to clean in the washing machine. Machine wash care is a concrete convenience for parents dealing with repeated mealtime messes.
- Mushroom Bib: Soft and highly absorbent, perfect for first bites, spit-up cleanup, and teething dribbles. These are the everyday situations the bib is intended for, so you can judge whether it matches your routine.
Butterfly Bib details that affect daily use
- Butterfly Bib: Perfect for any mealtime mess or teething troubles. The bib is positioned for the same broad mealtime and teething use as the Mushroom Bib.
- Butterfly Bib: Adjustable and easy to clean. Easy cleaning is mentioned, but the record does not specify machine washing, so check the care label before laundering.
- Butterfly Bib: Adorable butterfly design. If the butterfly print is the main appeal, this is the bib that delivers it; the Mushroom Bib offers a different motif.
How to choose between the two prints
If you want a bib that can switch between a print and a solid color, the Mushroom Bib is the clear choice because it is reversible. If you prefer the butterfly motif and want to spend slightly less, the Butterfly Bib is the better fit. For care, the Mushroom Bib explicitly states machine washing, while the Butterfly Bib only says easy to clean, so if machine washing matters to you, the Mushroom Bib is the safer bet based on the supplied information.
Both bibs use the same 8-inch by 9-inch muslin construction and 8-inch braided ties, so neither is larger or more absorbent according to the records. Your decision should come down to which design you prefer and whether reversibility or confirmed machine wash care is important to you.
What the records do not settle
The supplied information does not specify an age range for either bib, so you will need to judge suitability for your child based on the size and your own preferences. Neither record mentions snap closures, despite the search term snap bib sizing; both use braided ties. Absorbency is described as double layered muslin for both, but no further performance details are provided. If you need confirmation on washing instructions for the Butterfly Bib, check the care label on the product you receive.



